Chicken Manchurian Being Labelled As Pakistani Chinese Cuisine Sparks Backlash From Indian Foodies
Indian Twitter has gone into a state of collective meltdown over a chicken manchurian recipe. The recipe was published in the New York Times. Indians on Twitter have taken to latching onto the NYT article.
Chicken Manchurian is a common item on the menus of Chinese, Pakistani, and Indian restaurants around the world.
On this fine day on Twitter, Indian Twitter has gone into a state of collective meltdown over a Chicken Manchurian recipe that was published in the New York Times. Here's what happened.
NYT calls Chicken Manchurian a "stalwart of Pakistani Chinese cooking"
A stalwart of Pakistani Chinese cooking, chicken Manchurian is immensely popular at Chinese restaurants across South Asia. https://t.co/jorY16XePW pic.twitter.com/79hv3URnTm
¡ª The New York Times (@nytimes) March 26, 2023
Indians on Twitter have taken to latching onto the NYT article that referred to Chicken Manchurian as a "stalwart of Pakistani Chinese cooking" because they were unable to find enough globally popular things with somewhat ambiguous origins to claim today.
According to a South China Morning Post article, Nelson Wang, a third-generation Chinese chef, is thought to have invented Chicken Manchurian in Mumbai. Nevertheless, the NYT article stated that South Asian restaurants served the dish frequently, not that it was created in Pakistan.
According to the author, attempts to recreate the Chicken Manchurian dish served at Hsin Kuang in Lahore in the late 1990s led to the development of the specific recipe. That did not stop the "world war" from starting in the Twitter comments to the NYT article, though.
Indian users caused an uproar on Twitter
People on Twitter reminded the news portal that the dish has existed in India for ages. A man wrote, "@nytimes - I have been having Chicken Manchurian in India since the early 80s...do some research rather than just publishing what a PR agency sends u!"
@nytimes - I have been having Chicken Manchurian in India since early 80s...do some research rather than just publishing what a PR agency sends u!
¡ª Anurag Katriar (@KingKatriar) March 28, 2023
Pakistani users came to the discussion and said, "Indeed a classic Pakistani dish and seeing by the comments of Indians on trying to divert the ownership, it just proves the point that it¡¯s a classic Pakistani Chinese dish. We are not laying claim on bhaji folks so don¡¯t get riled up."
Indeed a classic Pakistani dish and seeing by the comments of Indians on trying to divert the ownership, it just proves the point that it¡¯s a classic Pakistani Chinese dish. We are not laying claim on bhaji folks so don¡¯t get riled up
¡ª Pak Politics (@pklections) March 27, 2023
"Hi, it was invented by an Indian Chinese chef called Nelson Wang, he was born in Calcutta. His restaurants are in Mumbai. "This is an Indian Chinese recipe," another Indian user pointed out.
Hi, it was invented by an Indian Chinese chef called Nelson Wang, he was born in Calcutta. His restaurants are in Mumbai. This is an Indian Chinese recipe.
¡ª Nayanika (@nayanikaaa) March 27, 2023
A man wrote, "Indians after adopting persian & central asian cuisine & making it their own are now saying a chinese dish which was invented by a chinese immigrant in india is 100% indian. Okay."
Indians after adopting persian & central asian cuisine & making it their own are now saying a chinese dish which was invented by a chinese immigrant in india is 100% indian. Okay.
¡ª Saoshyant (@ShyantSao) March 27, 2023
The History Of Chicken Manchurian
Flickr
As per online reports, the origins of Chicken Manchurian can be traced back to the 1970s in Pakistan, when a local chef named Ali Sikandar Tahir experimented with the Chinese-style cooking techniques and spices he had learned while working in Chinese restaurants in Karachi. Tahir combined these techniques with Pakistani ingredients and flavours, and the result was a dish that was both Chinese and Pakistani in flavour.
The dish gained popularity in the 1980s in Pakistan and then spread to India. Over time, it has become a staple of Pakistani Chinese cuisine and is now widely available in restaurants in both countries.
Another report published in 2017 by the South China Morning Post (SCMP) talks about how chicken manchurian found its place in Indian cuisine. It mentioned that chicken manchurian was apparently created by Nelson Wang, a third-generation Chinese chef born in India.
What do you think about this? Tell us in the comments.
For more trending stories, follow us on Telegram.
I'm a writer with a zest for life and a knack for turning everyday moments into captivating stories. Whether you're a haute couture enthusiast or a thrift shop aficionado, I've got style tips that'll make heads turn. But what truly sets my heart on fire is writing about queer issues. I'm here to amplify diverse voices and stories.
Read More
