Why The Post Merger Math Seems To Be Working Against HDFC Bank Stock

It has already been more than four months since home loan lender HDFC Ltd got merged with HDFC Bank, which currently has a market cap of more than Rs 11 lakh crore (Rs 11 trillion).

The merger had come into effect from July 1, 2023, post which the merged entity's stock has been trading more than 13% lower than its stock price pre-merger.

What Is HDFC Bank's Share Price?

mint

HDFC Bank¡¯s share price on July 1 2023 was Rs 1719.80 and is currently trading over 13% lower at around Rs 1480-1490.

How Did HDFC Perform Post Merger?

India¡¯s stock market analysts seem to have turned cautious on shares of HDFC Bank after the lender¡¯s July-September quarter (Q2FY24) scorecard revealed margin concerns post-merger with erstwhile HDFC and a fall in earnings per share (EPS) growth for the period.

As per Moneycontrol¡¯s Analyst Call Tracker for October, analysts did not share maximum optimism with India¡¯s largest private sector lender. HDFC Bank used to consistently feature among Street¡¯s top 10 favourite picks in the previous months. Other lenders like ICICI Bank, Axis Bank, IndusInd Bank, and State Bank of India, however, continued to dominate analysts¡¯ minds in October.

Which Reasons Are Making Analysts Conservative Over HDFC Bank?

istock

These are some of the reasons why analysts are not turning out to be in favour of HDFC Bank's stock:

-Bleak margin outlook

Nuvama Institutional Equities, for instance, believes that there is near-term uncertainty on the banks¡¯ margin trajectory and their ability to deliver consistent deposit growth every quarter.

In Q2FY24, HDFC Bank¡¯s net interest margins (NIMs) contracted to 3.4 percent due to merger management and regulatory impact caused by incremental cash reserve ratio (ICRR), which was 5-10 bps for the quarter, as per Money Control.

The regulation on ICRR has now been withdrawn, which analysts believe should result in a reversing trend from Q3FY24. However, the normalisation of NIM at 3.65 percent is unlikely in the next one or two quarters and may take longer due to the high cost of erstwhile HDFC borrowings and loan-to-deposit ratio.

Thus, given margin pressures and lower benefit-of-cost ratios, analysts at Axis Securities trimmed earnings estimates for HDFC Bank by 2-5 percent over FY24-26E.

-Asset quality impacted slightly post-amalgamation

HDFC Bank¡¯s gross non-performing loan (NPL) ratio and net NPL ratio saw a sequential increase of 10 bps and 20 bps, respectively in the September-ended quarter. This was mainly on account of some slippages in the non-individual loan book from erstwhile HDFC.

The NPLs of combined HDFC and HDFC Bank were Rs 12,500 crore in Q2FY24, higher than Rs 8,950 crore in the year-ago period.

However, the bank has maintained a healthy provisioning coverage ratio (PCR) at 74 percent which would provide comfort in the long term. PCR is the percentage of funds that a bank sets aside for losses due to bad debts. A high PCR can prove to be beneficial to banks to buffer themselves against losses if NPAs start to increase at a faster rate. As per RBI guidelines, PCR above 70 percent is considered to be healthy.

ET

-The double fall in stock price and EPS

The EPS growth of HDFC Bank fell significantly to 10.8 percent year-on-year (YoY) in Q2FY24 as compared to 20 percent growth seen in the previous quarter. This fall in EPS growth was reflective of bourses as well. The stock of HDFC Bank slipped 9 percent in three months as against a 2 percent drop in the Bank Nifty index.

The sharp correction, analysts said, was first majorly due to uncertainty around the merger and later due to merger math being weaker than initial estimates.

What Next For HDFC Bank?

That said, analysts at Kotak Institutional Equities assume the worst of merger-related news flow would be worked through and the bank may be able to grow with fewer concerns hereon. They expect HDFC Bank¡¯s balance sheet to grow at a marginally faster rate than the industry average.

¡°We maintain ¡®buy¡¯ rating for HDFC Bank with target price of Rs 1,800 per share. At our target price, we value the bank 2.6 times (x) book and 17x 2025E EPS for return of equities (ROEs) at 16 percent levels and 15 percent compounded annual growth rate (CAGR),¡± the brokerage firm added, as per the report.

On the other hand, analysts at Nuvama believe that a gradual re-rating for HDFC Bank would depend on how consistently the bank is delivering loan and deposit growth. The management is confident of delivering strong and granular loan and deposit growth.

Meanwhile, analysts at Motilal Oswal said that the bank posed a good beginning post-merger but still has a long way to go. ¡°We estimate HDFC Bank to deliver a CAGR of 18/20 percent in loans/deposits and 21 percent CAGR in earnings over FY24-26, translating into RoA/RoE of 2/17.4 percent by FY26E,¡± they wrote in a post-result review note.

For the latest and interesting financial news, keep reading Indiatimes Worth. Click here.